Our All-Star Ballot: The Best at Every Slot

Our All-Star rosters — the best player at every position by our own metrics.

These are our All-Star picks, one name per position chosen by our metrics, not by who got the most clicks. Some slots were never in doubt. Others came down to a few points.

American League All-Stars

Our All-Star roster — the best bat at each position by our MVP Score, the top starter by Cy Young Score, and a setup reliever and closer by form.

Yordan Alvarez runs away with the DH spot at 85.4, a .320 average and 25 homers that nobody else in the league touches. The fun call is at first, where Ben Rice (81.1) edges in front after years of thin Yankee production at the bag, while Byron Buxton's 77.2 in center quietly leads a deeper field; closer Louis Varland gets the nod at a 95 form with a 0.84 ERA.

• CDillon DinglerDetroit Tigers · .266 AVG · 18 HR · 56 RBI · 0.867 OPS75.8SCORE›
• 1BBen RiceNew York Yankees · .285 AVG · 22 HR · 53 RBI · 0.969 OPS81.1SCORE›
• 2BJazz Chisholm Jr.New York Yankees · .230 AVG · 12 HR · 33 RBI · 0.725 OPS60.9SCORE›
• 3BJunior CamineroTampa Bay Rays · .285 AVG · 19 HR · 43 RBI · 0.896 OPS74.8SCORE›
• SSColson MontgomeryChicago White Sox · .219 AVG · 20 HR · 46 RBI · 0.799 OPS71.3SCORE›
• LFCody BellingerNew York Yankees · .270 AVG · 11 HR · 49 RBI · 0.831 OPS66.0SCORE›
• CFByron BuxtonMinnesota Twins · .270 AVG · 25 HR · 41 RBI · 0.912 OPS77.2SCORE›
• RFJac CaglianoneKansas City Royals · .268 AVG · 14 HR · 30 RBI · 0.822 OPS66.9SCORE›
• DHYordan AlvarezHouston Astros · .320 AVG · 25 HR · 56 RBI · 1.062 OPS85.4SCORE›
• SPCam SchlittlerNew York Yankees · 1.69 ERA · 0.90 WHIP · 110 K84.3SCORE›
• RPColin HoldermanCleveland Guardians · 1.59 ERA · 0.78 WHIP · 7 HLD · 32 K · 89% clean99SCORE›
• CLLouis VarlandToronto Blue Jays · 0.84 ERA · 0.93 WHIP · 16 SV · 5 HLD · 58 K · 92% clean95SCORE›

National League All-Stars

Our All-Star roster — the best bat at each position by our MVP Score, the top starter by Cy Young Score, and a setup reliever and closer by form.

Kyle Schwarber's 79.9 and 29 home runs make him the easy DH pick, but the headliner is Jacob Misiorowski, whose 89.1 starter Score towers over everyone in either league behind a 1.45 ERA. Juan Soto takes left at 77.9, and Washington lands two more in CJ Abrams (75.8) at short and James Wood (76.9) in right. Mason Miller closes it out at a perfect 100 form.

• CDrake BaldwinAtlanta Braves · .268 AVG · 14 HR · 39 RBI · 0.835 OPS72.5SCORE›
• 1BMatt OlsonAtlanta Braves · .270 AVG · 20 HR · 52 RBI · 0.870 OPS75.5SCORE›
• 2BBrandon LowePittsburgh Pirates · .249 AVG · 19 HR · 51 RBI · 0.841 OPS73.9SCORE›
• 3BMax MuncyLos Angeles Dodgers · .266 AVG · 16 HR · 34 RBI · 0.873 OPS73.2SCORE›
• SSCJ AbramsWashington Nationals · .287 AVG · 17 HR · 57 RBI · 0.899 OPS75.8SCORE›
• LFJuan SotoNew York Mets · .299 AVG · 17 HR · 38 RBI · 0.968 OPS77.9SCORE›
• CFPete Crow-ArmstrongChicago Cubs · .287 AVG · 17 HR · 44 RBI · 0.889 OPS72.7SCORE›
• RFJames WoodWashington Nationals · .263 AVG · 20 HR · 49 RBI · 0.904 OPS76.9SCORE›
• DHKyle SchwarberPhiladelphia Phillies · .253 AVG · 29 HR · 52 RBI · 0.962 OPS79.9SCORE›
• SPJacob MisiorowskiMilwaukee Brewers · 1.45 ERA · 0.75 WHIP · 138 K89.1SCORE›
• RPDylan LeeAtlanta Braves · 1.04 ERA · 0.63 WHIP · 15 HLD · 42 K · 89% clean100SCORE›
• CLMason MillerSan Diego Padres · 0.79 ERA · 0.79 WHIP · 21 SV · 66 K · 94% clean100SCORE›

Stats via the MLB Stats API. Colors, form scores and power rankings are Baseball Lens's own.